Sunday, December 25, 2011

Pinwheel Cookies

So Alton Brown is a genius. The Food Network ran an old episode of Good Eats in which he made Christmas cookies this past week. One of the features was the Pinwheel Cookie.

 It looked fun enough that we gave it a try. Alton's recipes are often far trickier than they seem on the show. I guess that's the magic of TV coupled with a handful of years of culinary school.

You make a batch of sugar cookie dough and then halve it flavoring one half with melted, unsweetened chocolate and the other with smashed up candy canes (which are strangely abundant this time of year.) You then roll out the dough, stack them, and roll them to form a nifty swirl.

We had a pretty good time rolling them and only screamed for Mary to help us 4,000 times.

 You're supposed to let the loaf sit in the refrigerator for two hours, but since Alton didn't, we started after an hour. The two doughs cooled at different speeds leaving us with a cookie that baked at different speeds. This caused a problem, as you can see, since the chocolate part set up quite nicely and the peppermint part oozed all over the cookie sheet.




We'd doubled the recipe, so the second loaf stayed in the refrigerator overnight, and our results were much, much better.

Tasted good - fun to do - a lot of work for not very many cookies.







5 comments:

  1. You did a great job, Scott. They were fantastic and very pretty!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm so so so impressed! That looks better (and probably tastes better) than anything I've ever cooked. I had no idea you were a baker?

    ReplyDelete
  3. They look very pretty and very delicious!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Follow Up -

    Mary thinks the second batch ended up better because we had the chocolate portion on the outside and peppermint on the inside.

    I'll leave it to the discerning reader to decide. (But Mary's probably right . . . again.)

    ReplyDelete